When the announcement circulated yesterday about a one-day estate sale at the longtime Pasadena home of architectural historian Bob Winter, hearts dropped into stomachs all across the Southland.
It was widely known that Bob intended to leave his Arts & Crafts bungalow, built by the great Pasadena tile maker Ernest Batchelder and liberally festooned with rare tile, glass and metalwork, to his beloved Occidental College.
Less widely known was what the college planned to do with the National Register landmark. It is in no danger of being demolished; the facade and principal downstairs rooms are protected by a preservation easement. But would Oxy undertake the considerable expense of maintaining the property just as it was, as an off-campus lecture hall or visiting scholar’s residence? Or would they put it on the market?
The estate sale announcement settled that question firmly: Bob Winter’s home would be sold.
Scrolling through photos on the estate sale listing, it was obvious that the library had been thinned. Still there were hundreds of books laid out in banker’s boxes. Would the reference library that informed such iconic Southern California histories as The California Bungalow, California Design 1910, Batchelder Tilemaker and A Guide to Architecture in Los Angeles and Southern California be dispersed?
The answer is “absolutely not!”
We reached out to our friends at Occidental College and got the skinny from Dale Ann Stieber, Special Collections Librarian and College Archivist:
“Three faculty members and two librarians reviewed Dr. Winter’s books and selected about 250-300 items for subject matter of regional value (arts & crafts and California regional arts, architecture and culture) for Occidental College Library.
Dr. Winter’s personal and professional papers, memorabilia, awards, and research files/books were reviewed, packed and will be coming to Special Collections. Ann Scheid, USC architectural librarian and a close friend and colleague of Dr. Winter, is assisting us in the processing of these materials for future researcher access. I should add that a decade ago Dr. Winter transferred his comprehensive 35mm slide collection on Southern California architecture to Occidental College; it has been fully digitized [alternate link], described and available in ArtStor.”
And that’s a bit of happy news on the sad occasion of the end of our friend Bob Winter’s life in his lovely bungalow. May this place attract a fine new steward and be a joyous and creative home for many years to come.
As for us, we’re skipping the estate sale, and prefer to remember the house filled with Bob’s personality and treasures. Having learned how to give offbeat Los Angeles architecture and history tours directly from the master (including one of Batchelder’s Dutch Chocolate Shop), we’ll be deep in South LA on Saturday, exploring the sites that figure in Patty Hearst’s kidnapping and the SWAT raid that incinerated her SLA captors.
We don’t begrudge anyone who swings by the sale in search of a keepsake, but if you’d like to explore the city Bob loved, why not come along for the ride? There’s time for both, and Los Angeles is calling.
Oldest friends Jean Bruce Poole (senior curator and historic museum director, El Pueblo) and Bob Winter enjoy a sunbeam in his living room, Winter 2015
Kim, Thank you for this evocation of the wonderful, wise and witty Dr. Winter. I’m glad and grateful that an easement is in place to protect the important interior spaces as well as the exterior of the Batchelder House. One hope the next owners will continue the tradition with the current neighbors to amicably “share” the full depth of the rear garden. I must say I was never under any illusion that Oxy would not sell the house once Bob was no longer with us. It is one of those houses that is best lived in, in my view, preferably by someone who knew Bob and fully appreciates its importance as a hub of the Arroyo culture that Bob cared so deeply about. I only hope that the proceeds from the sale of the house will go to a cause that Dr. Winter might have approved. Perhaps restoring and carrying out programs (as Oxy has said they would like to do) at the Lummis Home?
Ted
Thanks for reading, Ted, and for your thoughtful speculation. I’m looking forward to seeing what happens to the house, and how this generous gift is used. The activation of Lummis House by Oxy’s Institute for the Study of Los Angeles sounds like a perfect match!
Hello Kim,
I just found your post and am wondering about the status of the Batchelder home.
Thank you very much.
Richard Arnold, San Gabriel
Hi Richard, we understand that Occidental has been shopping the house around to a select group of potential buyers, and that it currently in escrow. Because the most historic elements of the building are protected by a preservation easement, we’re not worried about it being at risk of alteration, and look forward to learning who will be making Bob Winter’s home their own.